Is the Feast of the Seven Fishes Sicilian?
Partly, in the sense that matters. According to Britannica, the feast developed among Italian Americans who had emigrated from Sicily and other southern regions of Italy in the 19th and early 20th centuries. What they brought with them was not a meal called the Feast of the Seven Fishes, though, but the southern Italian Christmas Eve vigil, a meatless dinner that in a seafaring region naturally meant fish.
The name is American. Britannica dates its first known appearance in print to the 1980s, in a Philadelphia newspaper, fittingly, since the feast is especially popular in that city.
When Stacy Adimando, then executive editor of Saveur, researched it for a 2018 interview with NPR, the Italian food writers, chefs and experts she spoke to from all over the country had never heard of it. One told her it was "about as Italian as veal parmigiana", and added that if you told an Italian family there would be only seven fish dishes on Christmas Eve, they would ask where the rest of the food was.
So if your family has always done seven fishes and your grandmother came from Sicily, you are not wrong about the roots. You are keeping a Sicilian custom under an American name.
Why seven fishes?
Nobody knows for sure. The explanations most often given are the seven sacraments of the Catholic Church and the Seven Hills of Rome; others suggest the seven days of the week. Plenty of families do not stick to seven at all: Britannica notes that many prepare 3, 11, 13 or any other odd number, with an odd number of dishes said to bring good luck, while some serve 9 for the Holy Trinity times three or 12 for the Apostles.
The number is the American part. The habit of eating fish, and a lot of it, on the night before Christmas is the part that comes from Italy.
La Vigilia: why Italians eat fish on Christmas Eve
Traditionally, Catholics fasted and abstained from meat before major feast days, including Christmas. In southern Italy, where seafood was abundant and relatively cheap, families broke the Christmas Eve fast with a large meal of fish. In Italian, a meatless day or dish is di magro, lean. The rule no longer applies, but the dinner survived, and across the south it is still the custom to eat fish on 24 December.
The night is called la Vigilia di Natale, the Christmas vigil, and the meal is the cena della Vigilia. Families often go on to midnight Mass, and Christmas Day is then the big meat lunch.
What do Sicilians eat on Christmas Eve?

The historian Maria Oliveri, drawing on the 19th-century folklorist Giuseppe Pitrè, describes a Sicilian Christmas Eve that divided by money. For ordinary families the fish was baccalà, salt cod from the northern seas, long the standard "di magro" food for days of penance. Pitrè records it fried; boiled and dressed with parsley, olive oil, garlic, salt and pepper; a ghiotta, in a sauce of onion and fresh tomato; or a spizzateddu, fried in lard and finished in water.
Wealthier families preferred fresh fish, and above all eel, ancidda in Sicilian, along with moray. Eel was so much in demand at Christmas that the eels of Messina were not enough, and eels from the Veneto were shipped to the markets of Messina and Catania. In Modica, those with money made an eel pie, while poorer households made pies of cuttlefish, snails, cauliflower or onion. Pitrè noted that eel cost dearest of all at Christmas, so pastry cooks made imitation eels out of marzipan.
Around the fish went the other meatless dishes of the night: pasta caciata (baked pasta with cheese), sfincione and sfinci (fried dough), and scacciu, roasted chickpeas and hazelnuts to pick at. In Messina the fish of the Christmas season is stockfish, pesce stocco a ghiotta.
Today the table has changed. Oliveri notes that smoked salmon, tuna and swordfish and shrimp have largely taken over, and the eels of Pitrè's day, real or marzipan, have all but disappeared.
| Dish | What it is | Who ate it |
|---|---|---|
| Baccalà | Salt cod, fried, boiled, or stewed with onion and tomato | Most families |
| Anguilla (ancidda) | Eel, fresh, at its most expensive at Christmas | Families who could afford it |
| Pasticcio di anguille | Eel pie | The well off in Modica |
| Pesce stocco | Stockfish (dried cod), a ghiotta | Messina, at Christmas |
| Sfincione and sfinci | Palermo’s thick pizza, and fried dough | Palermo area |
| Scacciu | Roasted chickpeas and hazelnuts | Everyone, through the evening |
Seven fishes vs the Sicilian Vigilia
| Feast of the Seven Fishes | Sicilian Vigilia | |
|---|---|---|
| Where | Italian American homes; especially popular in Philadelphia | Sicilian homes |
| Name | Feast of the Seven Fishes, Christmas Eve Fish Dinner, the Vigil | La Vigilia di Natale, cena della Vigilia |
| Number of dishes | Seven, or another odd number | No set number |
| Typical fish | Baccalà, shrimp, clams, calamari, anything from lobster to fish sticks; eel among older generations | Baccalà, eel; stockfish in Messina at Christmas |
| Not fish | Pasta courses, sides | Sfincione, sfinci, pasta, chickpeas and nuts |
The American dishes in this table come from Britannica and from Stacy Adimando's description of her own family's table on NPR, which also includes a chilled seafood salad and linguine with clams.
A Sicilian Christmas Eve menu in seven fish
If you want to keep the American number but cook Sicilian, here is how I would build the seven from the dishes of the Sicilian Vigilia and the island's fish cooking. It is my suggestion, not a fixed tradition: in Sicily nobody counts.
- Fried baccalà: salt cod, the Christmas Eve fish of most Sicilian families in Pitrè's day.
- Baccalà a ghiotta: salt cod stewed with onion and fresh tomato, the other way Pitrè records it. In Messina, make it with stockfish instead, as pesce stocco a ghiotta.
- Eel: the classic luxury of the Sicilian Vigilia, once so sought after that extra eels were shipped from the Veneto to Messina and Catania.
- Swordfish with salmoriglio: swordfish dressed with Sicily's lemon, oil and oregano sauce, in my guide to classic Sicilian recipes. Oliveri notes that swordfish is on many Sicilian Christmas Eve tables today.
- Anchovies on sfincione: Palermo's thick Christmas Eve pizza is topped with anchovies; my Sicilian pizza guide has a recipe.
- Sardines in pasta con le sarde: Palermo's great fish pasta, in my guide to Sicilian pasta dishes. To be honest, in Sicily it is a dish of March to September, when fresh sardines and wild fennel are in season, so it is not a Sicilian Christmas tradition.
- Shrimp or tuna: Oliveri notes that shrimp and tuna, with swordfish and smoked salmon, have largely taken over the Sicilian Christmas Eve table today.
Around the fish, add what Sicilians served with it: baked pasta with cheese, sfinci (fried dough) and scacciu, roasted chickpeas and hazelnuts to pick at through the evening.
Spending Christmas Eve in Sicily
If you are in Sicily on 24 December, it is a family night: many shops close early, and the evening belongs to the big dinner and midnight Mass. My guide to Christmas in Sicily covers the whole season, from Santa Lucia on 13 December to Epiphany, including the living nativity scenes and what is open, and my guide to Sicily in December covers the weather and what else is on.
For the food, my Sicily food guide covers what to eat all year round, and my guide to Sicilian desserts has the Christmas sweets, buccellato and marzipan among them. If your family's Vigilia came over from Sicily and you are looking into your roots, my guide to Italian citizenship by descent explains how that works for Americans.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Feast of the Seven Fishes Sicilian?
Its roots are. The feast developed among Italian Americans whose families came from Sicily and other parts of southern Italy in the 19th and early 20th centuries, and it comes from the southern Italian custom of a meatless fish dinner on Christmas Eve. But the name and the number seven are American: in Sicily the meal is simply the Christmas Eve dinner, la cena della Vigilia, and nobody counts the dishes.
Is the Feast of the Seven Fishes an Italian tradition?
Not by that name. Britannica describes it as an Italian American Christmas Eve meal, and the first known printed mention of the name was in a Philadelphia newspaper in the 1980s. Italian food writers and chefs interviewed for a 2018 NPR report had never heard of it. Eating fish on Christmas Eve is, however, a real tradition across southern Italy.
Why is it called the Feast of the Seven Fishes?
Because Italian American families traditionally served seven fish dishes on Christmas Eve. No one knows for sure why seven: common explanations are the seven sacraments, the Seven Hills of Rome or the seven days of the week. Many families serve another odd number instead, such as 3, 11 or 13, for luck.
What do Sicilians eat on Christmas Eve?
Traditionally a meatless dinner: baccalà (salt cod), fried, boiled or stewed with onion and tomato, for most families, and fresh eel for those who could afford it. Around it went baked pasta with cheese, sfincione, fried dough (sfinci) and roasted chickpeas and hazelnuts. In Messina stockfish is the fish of the Christmas season. Today smoked salmon, tuna, swordfish and shrimp are common too.
What is La Vigilia?
La Vigilia di Natale is Italian for Christmas Eve, the vigil before Christmas Day. The meal that night is the cena della Vigilia, traditionally meatless because Catholics once fasted and abstained from meat before Christmas. In southern Italy and Sicily that meant a large fish dinner, the custom behind the Italian American Feast of the Seven Fishes.
Why do Italians eat fish on Christmas Eve?
Because Catholics were traditionally required to fast and abstain from meat on the day before Christmas. In southern Italy, where seafood was plentiful and relatively cheap, families broke the fast with a large meal of fish. The requirement no longer applies, but the custom has lasted.
When did the Feast of the Seven Fishes start?
The custom behind it came to the United States with southern Italian and Sicilian immigrants in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The name itself is much newer: according to Britannica, its first known appearance in print was in a Philadelphia newspaper in the 1980s.
What fish is traditional for Christmas Eve in Italy?
Baccalà (salt cod) is the most widespread, and eel is the classic luxury, especially in the south: in Naples it is capitone, a large female eel. In Sicily, eel was so sought after at Christmas that extra eels were shipped from the Veneto to Messina and Catania, and in Messina stockfish is the traditional fish of the Christmas season.
What are the seven fishes?
There is no fixed list. Italian American families choose their own: Britannica mentions baccalà, shrimp, clams and calamari, anything from lobster to fish sticks, and eel among older generations. On a Sicilian table the equivalents are baccalà and eel, stockfish in Messina, and today swordfish, tuna and shrimp.
What is a traditional Feast of the Seven Fishes menu?
There is no single traditional menu. Italian American families usually serve seven, or another odd number, of seafood dishes, such as baccalà, calamari, shrimp, linguine with clams and a chilled seafood salad. A Sicilian-style menu could run from fried baccalà and baccalà stewed with tomato to eel, swordfish with salmoriglio, sfincione with anchovies, pasta con le sarde and shrimp or tuna.
Sources and small print
- Britannica: Feast of the Seven Fishes
- NPR: Saveur magazine examines how the Feast of the 7 Fishes started (David Greene with Stacy Adimando, 18 December 2018)
- Balarm: La vigilia di Natale in Sicilia (Maria Oliveri, 24 December 2025, quoting Giuseppe Pitrè and Giuseppe Coria)
- Visit Sicily (Regione Siciliana): Christmas food in Sicily
Credits
Photo: Anastazja Kuroczycka, Unsplash Licence, via Unsplash.
Photo: Rino Porrovecchio, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

