Sicily vs Sardinia at a glance
| Sicily | Sardinia | Amalfi Coast | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | The largest island in the Mediterranean, 9,830 sq miles (25,460 km²) | The second largest, 9,301 sq miles (24,090 km²) | A stretch of coast on the Sorrento peninsula, south of Naples |
| Main city | Palermo | Cagliari | No city; Salerno is nearby |
| Airports | Catania, Palermo and others | Cagliari, Olbia, Alghero | Salerno Costa d’Amalfi |
| UNESCO World Heritage | Seven sites, from Agrigento to Etna | Su Nuraxi di Barumini (1997) and the domus de janas tombs (2025) | The whole Costiera Amalfitana (1997) |
| Best for | Culture, food, variety, islands | Beaches, sea, nature, a slower pace | A short stay with views |
| Nonstop flights from the US | Seasonal: Delta from New York JFK to Catania | Seasonal: Delta from New York JFK to Olbia, since May 2026 | None to Salerno; Naples is the main airport for the region |
| Getting around | A rental car, or trains and buses between cities | A rental car | Buses and boats; odd/even plate rules for cars in the busy months |
Why choose Sicily

Sicily's great strength is how much is packed into one island. It has seven UNESCO World Heritage sites: the Valley of the Temples at Agrigento, the Roman mosaics of the Villa Romana del Casale, Syracuse with the necropolis of Pantalica, the late baroque towns of the Val di Noto, the Aeolian Islands, Mount Etna, and the Arab-Norman monuments of Palermo, Cefalù and Monreale. Around them are beaches, small islands and some of the best food in Italy. My list of the best things to do in Sicily puts them in order, and my Sicily airports guide covers the nonstop flights from New York.
The trade-off is distance and planning: you cannot see it all in a week, and the roads take time. Pick one side of the island for a first visit. My Sicily itineraries guide has routes for one and two weeks, my guide to Sicily's beaches covers the coast, and my Sicily food guide explains what to eat, from arancini to cannoli.
Why choose Sardinia
Sardinia is for people who want the sea. Its coast is its great draw, from the coves of the east coast, such as Cala Goloritzè, whose rock pinnacle is in the photo above, to the north around Olbia. Inland, it has something no other Italian region has: the nuraghi, stone towers of the Bronze Age, of which Britannica counts about 7,000. The best known, Su Nuraxi at Barumini, is a UNESCO site, and in 2025 UNESCO added the domus de janas, prehistoric rock-cut tombs found across the island.
The food is its own, with pasta such as culurgionis from Ogliastra, stuffed with potato, pecorino and mint and closed in a shape like an ear of wheat, which has protected IGP status in the EU. You will want a car to explore the island. Sardinia has three main airports, at Cagliari, Olbia and Alghero, and ferry ports at Olbia, Golfo Aranci, Porto Torres, Cagliari and Arbatax.
Sicily vs the Amalfi Coast

The Amalfi Coast is a different kind of trip: one stretch of coast, on the Sorrento peninsula south of Naples, with towns such as Positano, Amalfi and Ravello stacked up cliffs above the sea. UNESCO listed the whole Costiera Amalfitana in 1997.
It is spectacular, compact and easy to enjoy in a few days, but it is busy in summer and the coast road is narrow: in the busy months, orders from ANAS, the road agency, and the coastal towns restrict cars on the SS163 coast road during the day on set dates, according to whether their number plate ends in an odd or even number. The dates, hours and exemptions change each year, so check the current rules before you plan to drive, or use the buses and boats.
Naples is the main airport for the region, and the nearest is Salerno Costa d'Amalfi; the Salerno Airlink connects it with Salerno, and from there SITA buses and ferries run along the coast. If you have a week or more, Sicily offers far more variety, and its eastern coast around Taormina has the same mix of cliffs, sea and views; my guide to Etna, Taormina, Catania and Siracusa covers it. If you are planning a honeymoon, my Sicily honeymoon guide has a 10-day route.
Which is better for which trip?
- First trip to southern Italy, a week or more: Sicily, for the most variety.
- A beach vacation: Sardinia, though Sicily's islands and coast run it close: think of the Aeolian Islands or the Zingaro coves.
- Ancient history: Sicily, for the Greek temples and theatres; Sardinia for the prehistoric nuraghi.
- Food: Sicily, with street food, pastries and wine regions to match its sights.
- Three or four days with views: the Amalfi Coast.
- Without a car: Sicily works between the main cities by train and bus; see my guide to Sicily without a car.
Comparing places to live rather than to visit? See my comparison of Sicily vs Tuscany for buyers and long stays.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, Sicily or Sardinia?
It depends on the trip. Sicily is better for variety, history and food, with seven UNESCO World Heritage sites, Greek temples, baroque towns, Etna and islands. Sardinia is better if the beach and the sea are the main point, with a quieter pace and its own prehistoric sites, the nuraghi.
Is Sardinia bigger than Sicily?
No. Sicily is the largest island in the Mediterranean, at about 9,830 square miles (25,460 km²), and Sardinia is the second largest, at about 9,301 square miles (24,090 km²). They are close in size.
Which has better beaches, Sicily or Sardinia?
Sardinia is the one to choose if beaches are the whole point, with coves such as Cala Goloritzè on its east coast. Sicily has excellent beaches too, on the main island and its small islands, and it lets you mix them with ancient sites and towns.
Is Sicily or the Amalfi Coast better?
For a short stay with views, the Amalfi Coast; for a week or more, Sicily, which offers far more variety: ancient sites, baroque towns, Etna, islands and beaches. The Amalfi Coast is also very busy in summer, when odd/even number-plate rules limit cars on its coast road.
Can you visit Sicily and Sardinia on the same trip?
Yes, but they are two large islands a long way apart, and the direct ferry, Grimaldi Lines between Palermo and Cagliari, sails about once a week and takes about 12 hours. With less than two weeks, it is better to choose one and see it properly.
Are there direct flights from the US to Sicily or Sardinia?
Yes, in season, from New York JFK. Delta flies nonstop to Catania in Sicily and, since May 2026, to Olbia in Sardinia. Both are summer routes, so check the airline for your dates; outside the season you change in Rome, Milan or another European hub.
Do you need a car in Sardinia?
In practice, yes, to explore the coast and the interior. In Sicily a car is the easiest way to get around too, but the main cities are linked by train and bus.
Sources and small print
- Britannica: Sicily and Sardinia
- Sardegna Turismo: how to get to Sardinia
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre: Italy, Su Nuraxi di Barumini, Costiera Amalfitana
- Eunews: Pizzoccheri e culurgionis guadagnano il marchio IGP (29 September 2016)
- Distretto Costa d'Amalfi: the ANAS odd/even plate order on the SS163 and how it works
- Delta News Hub: nonstop service from New York JFK to Catania and to Olbia, Sardinia
- Grimaldi Lines: Palermo to Cagliari ferry
- Aeroporto Salerno Costa d'Amalfi
Credits
Photo: Unukorno, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Photo: Henrique Ferreira, Unsplash Licence, via Unsplash.
Photo: Raymondlafourchette, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

