How much does it cost to live in Italy compared with the US?

Less, and in Sicily a lot less. On Numbeo's crowd-sourced country indices, which compare everything with New York and which I treat as indicative only, Italy scores about 61 for living costs excluding rent against about 70 for the US, and about 19 for rent against about 37. Sicily sits at the cheap end of Italy: on Immobiliare.it its average asking rent per square metre is roughly half the Italian average.

The official household surveys point the same way, with a caveat. ISTAT, the Italian statistics office, found that the average Sicilian household spent about €2,305 a month, about $2,540. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics found that the average American household spent $81,905 a year, about $6,830 a month. The two surveys do not count exactly the same things, so read that as a rough sense of scale rather than a precise gap.

Before any of this, the exchange rate. I use about $1.10 to the euro on this page, close to the European Central Bank's reference rate as I write. If the dollar weakens, Sicily gets dearer for anyone paid in dollars, so check the rate before you budget.

Sicily vs US prices, side by side

Sicily against the US, in dollars at about $1.10 to the euro
SicilyUS
Rent, typical advertised apartmentAbout $660 a monthMedian gross rent $1,557 a month
Home priceMedian asking price for an apartment about $93,500Median existing-home price about $416,700
Gas (petrol), per gallonAbout $8.20 to $8.30About $3.81 for regular
Diesel, per gallonAbout $9.20 to $9.30About $5.94
Electricity, per kWhAbout 47 cents (regulated price)About 18 cents on average
Milk, per gallonAbout $4.80About $4.11
Eggs, per dozenAbout $2.86About $2.27
Average household spendingAbout $2,540 a monthAbout $6,830 a month

Sicilian figures come from my cost of living in Sicily guide, where each one is sourced in euros: Immobiliare.it for rents and asking prices, the Italian ministry's fuel observatory, the energy regulator ARERA, Numbeo for groceries and ISTAT for household spending. US figures are from the Census Bureau, the National Association of Realtors, the Energy Information Administration and the Bureau of Labor Statistics. A gallon is 3.785 litres.

Two of those lines need a word of warning. The Sicilian electricity price is the regulator's figure for the regulated service, including taxes, and most households are on market contracts that vary. And eggs and milk are one city's crowd-sourced prices against a US national average, so they show the order of magnitude, not a precise difference.

Housing: rent and homes in Sicily vs the US

This is the big one. The US Census Bureau puts the national median gross rent at $1,557 a month. In Sicily the average advertised rent for an apartment is around €600, about $660, and Numbeo users put a one-bedroom apartment in central Palermo or Catania at around €580 to €620, about $640 to $680, and around €340 to €410, about $370 to $450, outside the centre.

Buying is even more different. The National Association of Realtors' latest median price for an existing home in the US is about $416,700. The median asking price for an apartment in Sicily on Immobiliare.it is around €85,000, about $93,500, and the island's average asking price works out at about $122 per square foot. We bought an abandoned house in western Sicily for €21,500, about $23,700, though the purchase was the cheap part.

If you are looking at listings, my page on finding homes for sale in Italy without Zillow explains the portals and how to read prices in square feet.

Gas, electricity and running a car

This is where Americans get a shock. In the weekly survey I used, the Energy Information Administration put the US average for regular gas at about $3.81 a gallon and diesel at about $5.94. Italian national averages were roughly €1.97 to €2.00 a litre for gasoline and €2.21 to €2.24 for diesel, which is about $8.20 to $8.30 and $9.20 to $9.30 a gallon. Even California, at about $5.39, was far below Italian prices.

Electricity is the same story. The EIA puts the average US residential price at about 18 cents per kWh. The Italian regulator's price for households still on the regulated service is about 43 euro cents including taxes, about 47 US cents.

Car insurance for third-party cover averaged about €422 a year nationally, about $464, according to the insurance regulator IVASS, though newcomers usually start on a worse rating. In the cities you may not need a car at all: a monthly bus pass in Palermo costs around €32, about $35. My guide to owning a car in Sicily covers licences, insurance and the rest.

Groceries, eating out and everyday costs

Supermarket staples cost about the same: on the figures above, milk and eggs are a little dearer in Sicily, while Numbeo's grocery index puts US groceries higher overall. Eating out is where Sicily is good value. The figures below are Numbeo users' prices for Palermo and Catania, which I treat as indicative.

Everyday prices in Palermo and Catania, in euros and dollars
EurosDollars
Cappuccino at the barAround €2About $2.20
Inexpensive restaurant meal, per personAround €13 to €15About $14 to $17
Mid range meal for two, three coursesAround €50About $55
Monthly gym membershipAround €55About $61
Mobile plan with plenty of data, per monthAround €9About $10
Home broadband, per monthAround €24 to €31About $26 to $34

Health care costs: Sicily vs the US

For many Americans this matters as much as rent. KFF's employer health benefits survey puts the average yearly premium for employer family coverage at $28,303, of which the worker pays $7,471, and single coverage at $9,804, of which the worker pays $1,672. That is before deductibles and copays.

In Italy, residents who work are normally enrolled in the national health service, the SSN, without a yearly fee, with small co-payments for some prescriptions and tests. People living in Italy without working, for example on the elective residence visa, usually enrol voluntarily, with a minimum yearly contribution of €2,000, about $2,200. Private insurance is the alternative, and its cost depends on your age and cover. My guide to healthcare in Sicily explains how the system works day to day.

How much do you need to live in Sicily, in dollars?

These are the monthly budgets from my cost of living guide, including rent, converted to dollars. They are built from Numbeo, Immobiliare.it, ISTAT and the car costs above, and they assume a simple, comfortable life rather than a luxurious one.

Indicative monthly budgets in Sicily including rent, in dollars at about $1.10 to the euro
HouseholdCityCountryside
Single personAbout $1,270 to $1,650About $1,100 to $1,490
CoupleAbout $1,870 to $2,530About $1,650 to $2,200
Family of fourAbout $3,080 to $4,180About $2,750 to $3,630

Your own number depends on rent, whether you need a car, health cover and how often you fly home. If you plan to move on your own income, the elective residence visa asks for proof of income, which the New York consulate typically puts at around €31,000 per person, about $34,000, which is well above these budgets. My guide to moving to Sicily from the US covers the rest of the move.

Frequently asked questions

Is it cheaper to live in Italy than the US?

For most Americans, yes, mainly because housing costs far less. On Numbeo’s indicative indices Italy scores about 61 for living costs excluding rent against about 70 for the US, and about 19 for rent against 37. Gas and electricity cost more in Italy.

How much does it cost to live in Italy per month in US dollars?

In Sicily, one of the cheaper regions, my indicative budgets including rent are about $1,270 to $1,650 a month for a single person in a city, $1,870 to $2,530 for a couple and $3,080 to $4,180 for a family of four, at about $1.10 to the euro. The countryside is a little cheaper if you do not count a second car.

Is rent cheaper in Sicily than in the US?

Much cheaper. A typical advertised rent in Sicily is about $660 a month, against a US national median gross rent of $1,557, and a one-bedroom apartment in central Palermo or Catania is around $640 to $680. Compare your own town’s rent with those figures.

How much is gas in Sicily compared with the US?

More than twice as much. Italian averages are roughly €1.97 to €2.00 a litre for gasoline, about $8.20 to $8.30 a gallon, against a US average of about $3.81 a gallon for regular. Diesel is about $9.20 to $9.30 a gallon in Italy against about $5.94 in the US.

Can I live in Italy on Social Security?

Possibly, but the visa sets the bar, not the cost of living. Most Americans who retire to Italy use the elective residence visa, and the New York consulate typically asks each applicant in a family application to show around €31,000, about $34,000, of stable income that is not from work. Social Security can count towards that.

Is health insurance cheaper in Italy than the US?

Usually much cheaper. Residents on the elective residence visa normally join the national health service voluntarily, with a minimum of €2,000 a year, about $2,200. The average US employer family premium is $28,303 a year, though the employer pays most of it.

What exchange rate do you use?

About $1.10 to the euro, close to the European Central Bank’s reference rate as I write. Every dollar figure on this page moves with the rate, so check the current one before you budget.

Sources and small print

Dollar figures are conversions at about $1.10 to the euro. Sicilian figures are explained in full on my cost of living in Sicily guide.

Credits

Photo: Stefano Huang, Unsplash Licence, via Unsplash.