Is there a Zillow for Italy?

Not in the way Americans mean it. Zillow works because almost every home for sale in the US goes into a local MLS run by agents, and the big sites draw on those feeds. Italy has no equivalent national database. There are private agent networks that share listings among their members, such as Listing+, which describes itself as about 2,700 professionals sharing around 40,000 listings a year, but nothing that covers the whole market.

So the Italian market is spread out. Sellers can, and in Sicily often do, give the same house to several agents at once on a non-exclusive basis, and each agent advertises it separately. Some owners sell privately. Some village houses are only ever offered by word of mouth or a sign in the window. What you get on the portals is a very large part of the market, but never the whole of it.

None of the portals gives you a Zestimate either. There is no automated value based on recorded sale prices; the asking price is simply what the seller and the agent hope to get. My guide to what property in Sicily really costs covers prices and the extra costs on top.

The nearest official benchmark is the property market observatory (OMI) of the Agenzia delle Entrate, Italy's tax agency. Twice a year it publishes, for each zone of every comune, a minimum and maximum value in euros per square metre, for sale and for rent, by type of property and condition. You can look the values up free on the agency's site by province, comune and zone, as a text search or on a map, or in its OMI Mobile app.

They are ranges, not the price of any one sale, and the agency itself warns that they are broad indications that cannot replace a valuation of the house by a qualified professional. Still, they tell you quickly whether an asking price is in the right area.

Where to find homes for sale in Italy

These are the sites that matter. I have no deal with any of them.

The main Italian property portals
SiteWhat it isUseful for
Immobiliare.itCalls itself Italy’s number one property portal, with over 1.2 million listings from agencies and private sellersThe widest search, price maps by town
idealistaAlso calls itself number one in Italy, and is the leading portal in Spain and Portugal; has an English versionSearching in English
Casa.itA national portal with agency and private listingsA second check, a filter for homes to renovate (da ristrutturare)
Subito.itItaly’s general classifieds site, with a property sectionPrivate sellers, cheap rural houses and land
Gate-away.comA site that promotes Italian real estate only to international buyers, with 45,000 or more listingsEnglish descriptions and agents used to foreign buyers

Run the same search on Immobiliare.it and idealista, then look on Subito.it for private sellers. In the US a buyer's agent would usually do this for you. In Italy the agent is, in law, an intermediary between buyer and seller rather than your representative, so the searching is mostly up to you. The guide to how estate agents work in Sicily explains why.

International sites such as Gate-away.com are useful, but they show the listings that agents have chosen to market abroad. When you find a house you like there, look for it on the Italian portals too and compare the details.

Homes for sale in Sicily: how the search works on the ground

Sicily is one of the cheapest regions in Italy to buy in, which is why so many Americans search for it. Immobiliare.it's figures put the average asking price in Sicily at about €1,192 per square metre, against about €2,229 for Italy as a whole. In dollars and square feet, that is about $122 per square foot in Sicily and about $228 for Italy. In Palermo the average is about €1,598 per square metre, about $163 per square foot.

A few things I learned searching here:

  • Search by comune (the town or municipality), not just by province. A province such as Trapani runs from busy coastal towns to quiet farming villages, and prices differ widely.
  • Expect duplicates. The same house can appear under three agencies with three slightly different prices and descriptions. That is normal here, not a scam, but compare them before you call anyone.
  • Go and look. Photos flatter, and the drive to a rural house tells you a lot. My guide to the best places to buy property in Sicily may help you choose where to start.
  • Talk to the agents in the town itself. Local agents often know of homes that are not yet on any portal, and a "vendesi" sign means for sale.

If you have seen the €1 houses, read the truth about Sicily's €1 homes first: they come with obligations, such as a renovation plan and a deadline.

For the steps after you find a house, from the offer to the notary, my practical guide to buying property in Sicily and my guide for American buyers cover the process. I will not repeat it here.

How to read an Italian real estate listing

Italian listings look familiar but measure things differently. Here is how I translate them.

Reading an Italian listing in US terms
On the listingWhat it means
m² (metri quadri)Square metres. Multiply by 10.764 for square feet: 100 m² is about 1,076 sq ft
€/m²Price per square metre. Divide by 10.764, then multiply by about 1.10, for dollars per square foot
Locali or vaniRooms, not bedrooms. A trilocale has three rooms; check the floor plan to see how many are bedrooms
Classe energeticaThe energy class from the energy certificate (APE), from A4, the best, down to G
Spese condominialiYour share of the running costs of a shared building, much like HOA or condo fees
Da ristrutturareNeeds renovating, anything from tired to a roofless ruin
Rustico or casaleA rural or farm building, often old stone

Italian law requires sale and rental adverts to show the home's energy class and its energy performance figure, so a listing that leaves them out entirely is worth asking about. Very old ruins with no usable rooms can be exempt. My Italian property glossary explains many more of the words you will meet.

Ask the agent how the square metres were measured, for example whether walls, balconies or terraces are included, and compare the figure with the floor plan held by the land registry (the planimetria catastale).

Who pays the real estate agent in Italy?

Usually both of you. Under the Italian civil code, an agent (mediatore) whose work leads to the sale is entitled to commission from each of the parties. That surprises most Americans, who are used to the seller paying. The rate is not fixed by law and varies by agent, so ask what it is before you view, and get it in writing.

An agent in Italy must be registered with the local Chamber of Commerce (Camera di Commercio). Ask for the registration number before you hand over any money, and check it. My guide to estate agents in Sicily covers commission, the agent's duties and what to ask.

Red flags on Italian property listings

Most listings are honest, if optimistic. These are the things that make me slow down:

  • Anyone asking for a deposit or a holding fee before you have seen the house, the paperwork and the agent's registration.
  • A price far below everything else in the same town, with few photos and no address beyond the province.
  • Interior photos missing on a house described as habitable, or only photos taken from a distance.
  • No energy class and no explanation.
  • "Sea view" or "near the beach" with no distance given. Check on a map.
  • Rural houses with no mention of water, power or road access. In the Sicilian countryside none of them can be taken for granted.

My guide to the biggest red flags when buying property in Sicily goes further into the paperwork, and the buying a house in Sicily checklist lists what to check before you sign anything.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a Zillow for Italy?

No. Italy has no national MLS, so no single site lists every home for sale. The closest equivalents are the big portals Immobiliare.it and idealista, with Casa.it, Subito.it and Gate-away.com covering more. Search two or three of them and talk to agents in the town you like.

What is the best website to find homes for sale in Italy?

Immobiliare.it and idealista are the two largest, and between them they carry most homes listed by agents. idealista has an English version. Subito.it is good for private sellers, and Gate-away.com is aimed at international buyers. I set up the same search with alerts on more than one site.

Does Italy have an MLS?

Not a national one. There are private networks where member agents share listings, such as Listing+, but most homes are advertised by each agent separately on the portals, often by several agents at once.

How much are homes for sale in Sicily?

Immobiliare.it puts the average asking price in Sicily at about €1,192 per square metre, about $122 per square foot at $1.10 to the euro, roughly half the Italian average. Prices vary widely: city apartments cost more, and houses needing work in inland villages far less.

Can I see sold prices for homes in Italy?

Not house by house, the way Zillow shows them. The nearest official source is the OMI property market observatory of the Agenzia delle Entrate, which publishes free, twice a year, a minimum and maximum value in euros per square metre for each zone of every comune, by type of property and condition. These are broad ranges, not individual sale prices, and they do not replace a valuation by a qualified professional.

How do I convert square metres to square feet on an Italian listing?

Multiply the square metres by 10.764. A 100 m² home is about 1,076 square feet. For price per square foot, divide the euros per square metre by 10.764 and multiply by the exchange rate.

Who pays the real estate agent commission in Italy?

Usually both buyer and seller. The Italian civil code entitles an agent whose work leads to the sale to commission from each party. The rate is not set by law, so agree it in writing before you view.

Can Americans buy property in Italy?

Yes. Americans can buy homes in Italy, and you need an Italian tax code, the codice fiscale, before you make an offer. My guide for American buyers covers the process, the notary and moving money from the US.

What does trilocale mean on an Italian listing?

A home with three rooms. Italian listings count rooms (locali or vani), not bedrooms, so a trilocale is not a three-bedroom home. Check the floor plan to see how many of the rooms are bedrooms.

Sources and small print

Dollar figures use about $1.10 to the euro, close to the European Central Bank's reference rate as I write. The rate moves, so check it before you budget.

Credits

Photo: Maria Lammert, Unsplash Licence, via Unsplash.